Skip to main content

Best Pizza in Sunset Park, Brooklyn

Thin Crust. Fiero Forni. No Shortcuts.
Handmade Pies, No Shortcuts

Handmade Pies, No Shortcuts

Fresh dough, real sauce, toppings from producers we trust. This is Brooklyn pizza with an Italian soul — come find us on Fifth Avenue.
Order Now
Crispy, Thin, Made From Scratch

Crispy, Thin, Made From Scratch

Tina Casale grew up in her family's pizza business. Every pie we make carries that — fresh ingredients, real dough, nothing from a bag.
See the Menu

From Our Kitchen

A Backyard in Greenwood Heights

A Backyard in Greenwood Heights

String lights, picnic tables, exposed brick inside. The kind of spot you want to stay at longer than you planned.
Private Events

The Story Behind Every Pie

Tina Casale grew up in the pizza business — and in 2022, she brought everything she learned home to Brooklyn. Every pie carries that history.

Great spot for a lowkey, intimate birthday dinner with family or a casual bite with friends! The seasonal salad is a must. The arugula pizza was a group favorite as well. Thank you to Tina and team for helping host our group of 18– so welcoming, attentive and yum. Throwback playlist was a plus.

Jasmine M.

Stumbled upon this pizza place after a stroll through Greenwood. The staff was attentive, even though we were there during off hours and the pizza was fantastic! We ordered the Mr. William and would recommend to anyone visiting Brooklyn!

Kennedy P.

Such a gem in the neighborhood if you like a really crispy crust, proper sauce and high quality ingredients! I highly recommend sausage pizza and mushroom with ricotta pizza. Delicious. Shared a pizza among 2 adults, 2 kids. Perfect size.

Judy B.

One of my favorite pizza spots! I love the Mr. William pizza and homemade meatballs. The service here is always so friendly, kind, and fast. There is ample seating inside and the ambiance is very peaceful. The outdoor seating is perfect, I can't wait until it's warm enough again to enjoy a slice under the fairy lights!

Annette V.

First rate pizza! Absolutely spectacular. And don’t sleep in the Caesar salad. Amazing service, vibe, killer playlist. This is a restaurant you’ll want to repeat again and again.

Casey C.

Featured

View menu

Frequently Asked Questions

What are you known for?

We’re known for Italian pizza, comforting pasta, hearty heroes, fresh salads, and classic drinks served across Sunset Park, Brooklyn.

  • Italian Food: Italian favorites range from specialty pizzas and pasta to meatballs, eggplant dishes, and house-made tiramisu. Examples include The Astarita Pizza, Rigattoni W/ Vodka Sauce, Homemade Meatballs, Eggplant Rollitini, and Housemade Tiramisu.
  • Pizza: The pizza selection features classic, vegetable, cheese, and truffle-topped pies. Examples include Margarita Pizza (16"), Quattro Formaggi Pizza, Greenwood Vegetable Pizza, Truffle Oil Pizza, and New York Style.
  • Drinks: Drinks include sodas, sparkling water, Italian citrus beverages, and juice for kids. Examples include San Pellegrino, Limonata, Aranciata, Coke, and Kids Juice.
  • Pasta: Pasta choices pair linguini, rigatoni, and pesto pasta with tomato, vodka, or meatball preparations. Examples include Pesto Pasta, Linguini With Tomato Sauce, Rigattoni W/ Vodka Sauce, and Linguini + Meatball.
  • Hoagies: Hero options feature meatball, prosciutto, and Caprese fillings. Examples include #2 Meatball Hero, #1 Prosciutto Hero, and #4 Caprese Hero.

Additionally, explore Salads and Sandwiches.

We are also known for Pizza, Gluten Free Pizza, and Brick Oven Pizza.

What meals do you serve?

We serve Lunch and Dinner

Do you offer delivery or takeout?

Yes, we offer Takeout and Delivery

Where are you located?

We are located in Brooklyn, NY at 797 5th Ave

What areas do you serve?

We serve the following areas: Jersey City, Greenwood Heights, Greenwood Cemetery, Brooklyn, Gowanus, Red Hook, Sunset Park, Park Slope, South Slope, Kensington, Prospect Park, Windsor Terrace, Borough Park, Bayonne, New York, Prospect Lefferts Gardens, Hoboken, Carroll Gardens, Fort Greene, and Flatbush.

Our location

Map showing the location of The Astarita on 797 5th Ave in Brooklyn
The Astarita

Brooklyn, NY

Loading today's hours...
Order online
Order with AppOrder online